Why does cigar cellophane turn yellow?
Cigar cellophane turns yellow as oils and other compounds from the tobacco gradually transfer to the sleeve. The tint can deepen in storage, but it cannot tell you the cigar’s age or prove it was stored well.
Five cigars came out of their sleeves for this comparison. Laid side by side on a white table, the empty sleeves range from almost clear to the color of weak tea, with one that looks downright amber. You can see the difference particularly well where the folded edges overlap. If you’ve opened a box and found just one yellow sleeve among its neighbors, you’ve seen a smaller version of the same thing.
What the empty sleeve tells you
A brown wrapper seen through clear cellophane can make the whole package look dark. Slip the cigar out and hold the empty sleeve over white paper. A tint that stays with the sleeve is consistent with tobacco compounds transferring to it over time. How much color you see varies from cigar to cigar. Working backward from a particular shade to a year of manufacture would be guesswork. A dated box or a purchase record gives you much better evidence.
Should you keep the sleeve?
Around a warehouse, a sleeve earns its keep whenever one cigar brushes against another. The same applies in a humidor drawer that gets opened and rearranged. If you leave yours on, you can write the purchase date on a small label and stick it to the sleeve. That gives the next amber one you find a little history of its own.
Boveda discusses both ways of storing cigars in its guide to humidor storage.
What to do when you find an amber sleeve
Set the empty sleeve next to the cigar on a white sheet of paper. Turn the sleeve over so the folded end lies flat. That thicker overlap often looks darker than the single layer along the side, even though both parts have spent exactly the same amount of time in the box. It’s one reason a photo of an unopened cigar can exaggerate how much color has transferred.
If the question is “Has my humidor been running dry?”, check the hygrometer and the condition of the wrapper. Yesterday’s humidity reading and the date you last replaced the pack are more useful for that question than the shade of the cello. We use 69% humidity-control packs for maintenance. A yellow sleeve alone gives you no reason to change the setting.
You can see the range of wrapper colors in our collection of all cigars.
About the contributor · Viviana covers cigar wrappers, tobacco appearance and storage for iHeartCigars.